Our Fault Review: Our Fault (or Culpa Nuestra, depending on where you’re watching) finally dropped, wrapping up the “Fault” trilogy that began with My Fault and Your Fault. I’ve been following this chaotic, fiery love story between Nick and Noah from the start, so yeah, I was curious, maybe even a bit hyped, to see how they’d end it.
While the first two movies gave fans the guilty-pleasure drama they came for, Our Fault feels like the tank finally hit empty. Let’s break it down.
My Rating: 3.0/5
| Category | Details |
|---|---|
| Title | Our Fault (Culpa Nuestra) |
| Franchise | My Fault (Culpa Mía) Trilogy – Final Chapter |
| Based On | Culpa Nuestra novel by Mercedes Ron |
| Genre | Romantic Drama, Teen Romance |
| Runtime | 1 hour 52 minutes |
| Director | Domingo González |
| Platform | Amazon Prime Video |
| Release Date | 16 October 2025 |
| Main Cast | Gabriel Guevara (Nick), Nicole Wallace (Noah), Marta Hazas, Iván Sánchez, Eva Ruiz |
The Story Picks Up Where It Left Off
Our Fault starts right after the events of Your Fault. Nick and Noah are apart, again, but not for long. Circumstances pull them back together through mutual friends, and before you know it, old flames start flickering again.
Nick’s now a full-on businessman, controlling his empire like he’s got everything figured out. Meanwhile, Noah’s still… lost. She’s jumping between people, emotions, and decisions like she’s trying to fill the void Nick left behind.
When they meet again, the tension is immediate. You can feel it, the attraction, the confusion, the emotional mess. It’s the kind of chemistry that could have carried the movie if the story had given it real fuel.
Nick and Noah: Chemistry Without Context
The Nick–Noah dynamic is the reason anyone’s still watching this trilogy. Their connection is raw, impulsive, and borderline toxic, but that’s also what made it addictive.
In this one, though, something’s missing. Sure, the looks and the heat are there, but the emotional thread that tied their chaos together in the first two films? Gone. It’s like watching sparks without fire, visually hot but emotionally cold.
Supporting Cast: Just Filling Space
New faces show up, but none of them really matter. They walk in, deliver a line or two, and disappear.
And then there’s Michael’s character, what a waste. The script sets him up like he’ll play a key role, but nope. The story sidelines him so hard you almost forget he exists.
It’s frustrating because the trilogy had room to expand beyond just Nick and Noah, but this final chapter never takes that chance.
The Plot: Drifting Without Direction
You know that feeling when you can tell a movie’s just… coasting? That’s Our Fault in a nutshell.
Scenes play out, people argue, some steamy glances happen, and that’s it. There’s no deeper message, no strong emotional pull. It’s as if the writers thought two hot moments and nostalgia for the earlier movies would be enough. Spoiler: it’s not.
If you’re watching purely for the adult scenes, you’ll find two, around the 21-minute and 56-minute marks. They’re shot well, with great lighting and chemistry, but that’s about it. Nothing new, nothing shocking.
Direction and Visuals Still Carry the Weight
One thing I’ll give credit for, the direction and camera work still slap. The film looks great. Every frame is glossy, seductive, and designed to pull you in. The color palette leans warm and intimate, matching the tone of the series.
Even when the story falls apart, the cinematography tries to hold it together. And honestly, that’s the only reason I didn’t zone out halfway through.
The Writing Couldn’t Keep Up
The dialogue feels like a downgrade. The characters say things we’ve already heard before, “You don’t understand me,” “You still want me,” that kind of stuff.
There are a few solid emotional moments, especially toward the end, but it’s not enough to rescue the whole thing. It’s like the writers forgot how to build tension without relying on flashbacks or body language.
The Ending Saves It (Sort Of)
The ending feels right. After all the drama and emotional whiplash, the film gives Nick and Noah a conclusion that finally feels earned. It’s not perfect, but it’s satisfying.
It wraps the trilogy in a way that says, “Yeah, this is where it should end.” No unnecessary cliffhangers, no “Children’s Fault” nonsense (thank God). Just closure, messy, emotional, but final.
Good vs. Bad in “Our Fault”
| Good Things | Bad Things |
|---|---|
| Nick and Noah’s chemistry still sizzles | The story feels recycled |
| Cinematography is beautiful and mature | Weak emotional connection |
| The ending gives closure | Supporting cast is wasted |
| Music and lighting enhance the mood | Dialogue is predictable |
| Works as a guilty-pleasure watch | Fans expecting part 1–2 energy will be disappointed |
My Verdict
So, is Our Fault worth watching?
If you’ve seen My Fault and Your Fault, then yeah, watch it. You’ve already invested time and emotions into Nick and Noah’s chaos, so it’s only fair that you see how it all ends.
But if you’re coming in fresh, expecting deep storytelling or wild romance, you might find yourself checking your phone halfway through.
It’s a decent watch, not great. A “turn your brain off and enjoy the heat” kind of movie. For fans, it’s closure. For newcomers, it’s background noise.
Also Read: Splinter Cell: Deathwatch Review — Netflix Finally Revives the Stealth Legend
Conclusion
Our Fault ends the trilogy on a note that’s more warm sigh than loud applause. It’s stylish, it’s seductive, but it lacks the spark that made the earlier movies pop.
Nick and Noah deserved a stronger sendoff, something with more emotional depth and less repetition. Still, it’s not a complete miss. The film gives closure, and for long-time fans, that might be enough.
If you’re in it for the chemistry, the nostalgia, or just to finish what you started, go ahead. But if you’re hoping for something groundbreaking, you might want to lower your expectations first.
FAQs
Q1: Do I need to watch the first two movies before Our Fault?
Yes. The story continues directly from Your Fault, so jumping in here won’t make much sense.
Q2: How’s the chemistry between Nick and Noah this time?
Still strong visually, but emotionally weaker than before.
Q3: Are there many adult scenes in this one?
Only two major ones, around 21 and 56 minutes, both shot well, but nothing extreme.
Q4: Is this the last film in the series?
Yes, it feels like a proper ending. There’s no setup for another sequel.
Q5: Should I watch it in theaters or wait for streaming?
Streaming’s fine. It doesn’t demand a big-screen experience.